scute/doc/manual/scute.texi

\input texinfo                  @c -*- Texinfo -*-
@setfilename scute.info
@settitle The Scute Manual

@dircategory GNU Utilities
@direntry
* Scute: (scute).          PKCS #11 module for the OpenPGP Card
@end direntry

@include version.texi

@c Unify some of the indices.
@syncodeindex tp fn
@syncodeindex pg fn

@ifinfo
This file documents the Scute module.

This is Edition @value{EDITION}, last updated @value{UPDATED}, of
@cite{The Scute Manual}, for Version @value{VERSION}.

@c NOTE: Don't forget to update the year for the TeX version, too.
Copyright @copyright{} 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007 g10 Code GmbH.

The Scute Manual is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the
Free Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License, or (at your
option) any later version.

The Scute Manual is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but
WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the GNU
General Public License for more details.

You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public License
along with this program; if not, write to the Free Software Foundation,
Inc., 59 Temple Place - Suite 330, Boston, MA 02111-1307, USA

@end ifinfo

@iftex
@shorttitlepage The Scute Manual
@end iftex
@titlepage
@center @titlefont{The Scute Manual}
@sp 6
@center Edition @value{EDITION}
@sp 1
@center last updated @value{UPDATED}
@sp 1
@center for version @value{VERSION}
@page
@vskip 0pt plus 1filll
Copyright @copyright{} 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007 g10 Code GmbH.


The Scute Manual is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the
Free Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License, or (at your
option) any later version.

The Scute Manual is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but
WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the GNU
General Public License for more details.

You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public License
along with this program; if not, write to the Free Software Foundation,
Inc., 59 Temple Place - Suite 330, Boston, MA 02111-1307, USA
@end titlepage
@page

@ifnottex
@node Top
@top Main Menu
This is Edition @value{EDITION}, last updated @value{UPDATED}, of
@cite{The Scute Manual}, for Version @value{VERSION} of the Scute
module.
@end ifnottex

@menu
* Introduction::                  How to use this manual.
* Preparation::                   What you should do before using Scute.
* Client Authentication::         How to use Scute for client authentication.
* Troubleshooting::               What to do when things go wrong.
* Internals::                     Technical details about Scute.

Appendices

* Copying::                       The GNU General Public License says
                                  how you can copy and share Scute.

Indices

* Concept Index::                 Index of concepts and programs.


@detailmenu
 --- The Detailed Node Listing ---

Introduction

* Getting Started::               Purpose of the manual, and how to use it.
* Features::                      Reasons to install and use Scute.
* Overview::                      Basic architecture of the Scute module.

Preparation

* Prerequisites::                 Dependencies of Scute.
* Building the Source::           How to build Scute.
* Certificate Preparation::       Preparing certificates for use with Scute.

Client Authentication

* Application Configuration::     Preparing the application for use with Scute.
* Authentication With Service::   Using Scute for client authentication.

Troubleshooting

Internals

* Features and Limitations::      Details about the interfaces implemented.
* Developing Scute::              How to understand or improve Scute.
* Mozilla Compatibility::         Interoperability notes for Mozilla NSS.


@end detailmenu
@end menu

@node Introduction
@chapter Introduction

This is a PKCS #11 implementation for the GnuPG Agent using the GnuPG
Smart Card Daemon.  Currently, only the OpenPGP card is supported.

Scute enables use of the OpenPGP smart card in applications supporting
PKCS #11 compliant security tokens.  The main application at this time
is client authentication in Mozilla-based web browsers.  In the future,
other applications will be supported.


@menu
* Getting Started::               Purpose of the manual, and how to use it.
* Features::                      Reasons to install and use Scute.
* Overview::                      Basic architecture of the Scute module.
@end menu


@node Getting Started
@section Getting Started

This manual documents the Scute module, how it can be used for common
applications supported by it, and how it can be extended and improved by
programmers.  It is thus a user manual as well as a developer manual.

The reader is assumed to possess basic knowledge about cryptography in
general, and public key cryptography in particular.  The underlying
cryptographic engines that are used by the library are not explained,
but where necessary, special features or requirements are provided.

This manual can be used in several ways.  If read from the beginning to
the end, it gives a good introduction into the module and how it can be
used in an application.  Forward references are included where
necessary.  Later on, the manual can be used as a reference manual to
get just the information needed about any particular application of the
module.


@node Features
@section Features

Scute is currently the only implementation of PKCS #11 for the OpenPGP
smart card.  Apart from that, it offers a couple of other benefits:

@table @asis
@item it's free software
Anybody can use, modify, and redistribute it under the terms of the GNU
General Public License (@pxref{Copying}).

@item it's built to grow
Although Scute currently only provides a single function, client
authentication using OpenPGP smart cards in Mozilla-based web browsers,
it was built with the intention of supporting other applications as well
in the future.

@item it's easy
Building and installing Scute is easy, and preparing smart cards for use
with Scute is a snatch using the GnuPG 2.0 framework.  The integration
of Scute into the application is seamless.
@end table


@node Overview
@section Overview

Scute is a security device that implements the PKCS #11 interface for
security tokens.  Applications which know how to use the PKCS #11
interface to access security tokens for crytpographic operations can use
Scute to access the OpenPGP smart card.  An important example of such an
application is the Firefox web browser by the Mozilla project, which
uses the Mozilla Network Security Services library (NSS).

Scute itself does not include a driver for the smart card itself.
Instead, it uses the GnuPG 2.0 framework to access the smart cards and
associated data like certificates.  Scute acts as the glue between the
application and GnuPG 2.0.

Currently, only client authentication over HTTPS with Firefox using the
OpenPGP card is supported.  In this configuration, Scute allows users to
authenticate themselves to a remote web service without entering their
log-in information.


@node Preparation
@chapter Preparation

To use Scute, you first have to install the software.  You also have to
prepare each card you want to use with Scute before it can be used.
Furthermore, you need to configure the application to make use of Scute
for cryptographic operations.  This chapter explains each of these steps
in detail.

@menu
* Prerequisites::                 Dependencies of Scute.
* Building the Source::           How to build Scute.
* Certificate Preparation::       Preparing certificates for use with Scute.
@end menu


@node Prerequisites
@section Prerequisites

There are two types of dependencies for Scute: compile-time dependencies
and run-time dependencies.  The compile-time dependencies only need to
be fulfilled when Scute is compiled and installed.  The run-time
dependencies need to be fulfilled when Scute is used in an application.

Scute depends, in addition to the essential build utilities, on the
following packages at build time:

@table @code
@item libgpg-error
Scute uses the GnuPG 2.0 framework for error handling, so it depends on
the GPG error library.  The minimum version required is 0.7.

@item libassuan
Scute uses the GnuPG 2.0 framework for communication with the GPG Agent,
so it depends on the Assuan library.  The minimum version required is
0.6.10.
@end table

At run-time, in addition to the run-time versions of the above
libraries, you also need the following packages installed and
configured:

@table @asis
@item GnuPG
Scute uses the GnuPG 2.0 framework to access the OpenPGP card and for
certificate management.  The minimum version required is 2.0.0.

@strong{Caution:} A functional installation of GnuPG 2.0 requires a
running GPG Agent process, which must be advertised to the applications
via the @code{GPG_AGENT_INFO} environment variable.  Please make sure
that you fulfill this requirement before using Scute in an application,
running the Scute test suite, or preparing certificates as described in
@ref{Certificate Preparation}.  @xref{Invoking GPG-AGENT, , , gnupg,
Using the GNU Privacy Guard}, for details on how to run the GPG Agent.

@item Pinentry
Pinentry is a dependency of GnuPG 2.0, so it also needs to be installed
with it.

@item Firefox et al.
Firefox is the first application supported by Scute.  In the future,
other applications may be supported.  The applications are not
dependencies of Scute, but Scute can not be used stand-alone, so you can
not experience it without an application.
@end table


@node Building the Source
@section Building the Source

Scute does comply to the GNU coding standards and thus can be compiled
and installed according to the generic installation instructions found
in the source package in the file @code{INSTALL}.  There are no Scute
specific options to the configure script.

After installation, the @code{libscute.so} module file can be found in
the library directory of the installation path.


@node Certificate Preparation
@section Certificate Preparation

To use an OpenPGP card with Scute, it first has to be initialized by
generating or loading a key on the card, see
@uref{http://www.gnupg.org/(en)/howtos/card-howto/en/smartcard-howto.html,
the OpenPGP Card How-To}.  Then a certificate has to be created and
imported into GPGSM.  This task involves three steps: First, a
certificate signing request (@acronym{CSR}) has to be created that
matches the key on the card.  This certificate signing request then has
to be submitted to a certificate authority (@acronym{CA}), which will
create the certificate and send it back to you.  At last, the
certificate has to be imported into GPGSM.  This section will explain
all of these steps in detail.

Before you start, make sure that the GPG Agent is running, see
@ref{Prerequisites}.  There is no need to configure GPGSM, so you can
create a CSR with the command:

@example
$ gpgsm-gencert.sh > floppy-head.p10
Key type
 [1] RSA
 [2] Existing key
 [3] Direct from card
Your selection: 3
You selected: Direct from card
@end example

As we create a certificate for the OpenPGP Card, the option ``@code{[3]
Direct from card}'' should be selected.

@example
Card with S/N D27600012401010100010000051B0000 found
gpg-agent uses OPENPGP.3 as ssh key
Select key 
 [1] OPENPGP.1
 [2] OPENPGP.2
 [3] OPENPGP.3
 [4] back
Your selection: 3
You selected: OPENPGP.3
Key usage
 [1] sign, encrypt
 [2] sign
 [3] encrypt
Your selection: 2
You selected: sign
@end example

The only operation currently supported is client authentication.  For
this, the authentication key has to be selected.  This is the third key
on the card, so the options ``@code{[3] OPENPGP.3}'' and ``@code{[2]
sign}'' should be chosen.  Note that the key usage is only advisory, and
the CA may assign different capabilities.

@example
Name (DN)
> CN=Floppy Head,OU="Webserver Team",O="Snake Oil, Ltd",L="Snake Town",ST="Snake Desert",C=XY
E-Mail addresses (end with an empty line)
> floppy.head@@example.com
E-Mail addresses (end with an empty line)
> 
DNS Names (optional; end with an empty line)
> 
URIs (optional; end with an empty line)
> 
@end example

As a last step, the common name and e-mail address of the key owner need
to be specified by you.  The above are only an example for a fictious
person working at a fictious company.  DNS names are only meaningful for
server certificates and thus should be left empty.

We have now entered all required information and gpgsm will display what
it has gathered and ask whether to create the certificate request:

@example
Parameters for certificate request to create:
     1	Key-Type: card:OPENPGP.3
     2	Key-Length: 
     3	Key-Usage: sign
     4	Name-DN: CN=Floppy Head,OU="Webserver Team",O="Snake Oil, Ltd",L="Snake Town",ST="Snake Desert",C=XY
     5	Name-Email: floppy.head@@example.com

Really create such a CSR?
 [1] yes
 [2] no
Your selection: 1
You selected: yes
@end example

GPGSM will now start working on creating the request.  During this time
you will be asked once for a passphrase to unprotect the authentication
key on the card.  A pop up window will appear to ask for it.

When it is ready, you should see the final notice:

@example
  gpgsm: certificate request created
@end example

Now, you may look at the created request:

@example
$ cat floppy-head.p10
-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----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-----END CERTIFICATE REQUEST-----
$
@end example

The next step is to submit this certificate request to the CA, which can
then create a certificate and send it back to you.

If, for example, you use the CA @uref{http://www.cacert.org, CAcert},
then you can log into your account at the CAcert website, choose
``FIXME'', check ``FIXME'', paste the above request block into the text
field and click on ``Submit''.  If everything works correctly, a
certificate will be shown, which you can cut and paste into a new file
@file{floppy-head.crt}.

Alternatively if, for example, you set up your own CA with OpenSSL, then
you can create your own certificate by issueing a command similar
@code{openssl ca -in floppy-head.p10 -cert snakeoil-ca-rsa.crt -keyfile
snakeoil-ca-rsa.key -out floppy-head.crt}.  Please see the OpenSSL
documentation for more details on how to set up and administrate a
certificate authority infrastructure.

In any way you should end up with a certificate file
@file{floppy-head.crt}, which you then have to import into GPGSM.  It is
also recommended that you import the root certificate of the CA first in
the same fashion.

@example
$ gpgsm --import floppy-head.crt
gpgsm: certificate imported
  
gpgsm: total number processed: 1
gpgsm:               imported: 1
@end example

gpgsm tells you that it has imported the certificate.  It is now
associated with the key you used when creating the request.  To see the
content of your certificate, you may now enter:

@example
$ gpgsm -K Floppy
/home/foo/.gnupg/pubring.kbx
---------------------------
Serial number: 10
       Issuer: /CN=Snake Oil CA/OU=Certificate Authority/O=Snake Oil, Ltd/L=Snake Town/ST=Snake Desert/C=XY/EMail=ca@@snakeoil.dom
      Subject: /CN=Floppy Head/OU=Webserver Team/O=Snake Oil, Ltd/ST=Snake Desert/C=XY
     validity: 2006-11-11 14:09:12 through 2007-11-11 14:09:12
     key type: 1024 bit RSA
  fingerprint: EC:93:A2:55:C6:58:7F:C9:9E:96:DB:12:6E:64:99:54:BB:E1:94:68
@end example

The option ``@code{-K}'' is used above because this will only list
certificates for which a private key is available.  To see more details,
you may use ``@code{--dump-secret-keys}'' instead of ``@code{-K}''.


@node Client Authentication
@chapter Client Authentication

@menu
* Application Configuration::     Preparing the application for use with Scute.
* Authentication With Service::   Using Scute for client authentication.
@end menu

Scute allows you to authenticate yourself to a website securely without
entering a username or password by simply using your OpenPGP card.
Currently, only Mozilla-based browsers like Firefox are supported,
although other applications using Mozilla NSS or supporting PKCS #11
modules may work.


@node Application Configuration
@section Application Configuration

To prepare your application for use with Scute, you have to load the
Scute module as a PKCS #11 module into the application.  With Firefox,
this can be done by choosing @code{Edit->Preferences} in the menu.  In
the preferences configuration dialog, you should select the
@code{Advanced} configuration section, then the @code{Security} tab, and
then select @code{Security Devices} in the category @code{Certificates}.

@image{firefox-pref}

In the devices manager dialog, you can select @code{Load} to load a new
PKCS #11 device.

@image{firefox-dm-load-before}

In the pop-up dialog that follows, you can give a module name
(e.g. ``@code{Scute}'') and a module filename.  The latter should
correspond to the full file name of the installed Scute module file
@file{libscute.so}.  The default installation path is
@file{/usr/local/lib}, which would mean that you have to provide the
file name @file{/usr/local/lib/libscute.so}.  If you or your system
administrator installed Scute in a different location, you have to
adjust the file name correspondingly.

@image{firefox-dm-load}

After confirming installation of the security device, a pop-up window
should confirm that the module was successfully loaded, and an entry for
the security device should appear in the device manager list of
@code{Security Modules and Devices}.

@image{firefox-dm-load-after}

When you insert the OpenPGP card for which you generated and imported a
certificate earlier (see @ref{Certificate Preparation}), the device
manager should detect this security token and display some information
about it in the @code{Details} list when you select it from the module
list.

@image{firefox-dm-token-present}

FIXME: Add some documentation and screenshots for the certificate
manager.

@node Authentication With Service
@section Authentication With Service

Before you access a web service which requires client authentication,
for instance a fictious web service
@ifnottex
@indicateurl{https://example.com},
@end ifnottex
@iftex
@code{https://example.com},
@end iftex
the OpenPGP card should be present.  In this case, a pop-up window will
appear that requests you to enter the PIN number protecting the
authentication key on the OpenPGP card.  After entering the PIN number,
your browser will be authenticated to the server.  If the server accepts
your request and certificate, this is all which is required.  You should
leave the card in the reader as long as the connection persists.
Depending on how aggressively GPG Agent caches your PIN number, you may
have to enter the PIN number again later to keep up the connection to
the server.

If the card is not present, or you enter the wrong PIN, or the server
does not admit your certificate, you will get an error message.  This
error message is generated by the application and Scute can not
influence it.  Unfortunately, in Firefox 1, this error message is not
very user friendly: ``@code{example.com has received an incorrect or
unexpected message.  Error code: -12227}''.

FIXME: Screenshot.

FIXME: Document possible error codes.


@node Troubleshooting
@chapter Troubleshooting

@strong{Symptom:} Loading the Scute security device in the security
device manager of Firefox fails with "Unable to load module".

@strong{Solution:} Make sure that Scute is correctly installed, and that
all libraries and executables are available.  Make sure that the GPG
Agent is running and can be found via the environment variable
@code{GPG_AGENT_INFO}.  @xref{Invoking GPG-AGENT, , , gnupg, Using the
GNU Privacy Guard}, for details on how to run the GPG Agent.


@strong{Symptom:} Client authentication fails with "<example.com> has
received an incorrect or unexpected message.  Error code: -12227".

@strong{Solution:} Make sure that the correct OpenPGP card is inserted
and the certificate available in GPGSM.  Check that the OpenPGP card is
detected correctly in the security device manager and the corresponding
certificate is displayed in the certificate manager of Firefox.
@xref{Authentication With Service}.


@strong{Symptom:} The OpenPGP card is detected and displayed in the
security device manager in Firefox, but no corresponding certificate is
displayed in the certificate manager of Firefox.

@strong{Solution:} Make sure that the corresponding certificate is
imported in GPGSM.

FIXME: Can this really happen???


@node Internals
@chapter Internals

The following notes are intended for people interested in more technical
details about Scute and its implementation.  They give an overview about
its scope and potential compatibility issues with applications.

@menu
* Features and Limitations::      Details about the interfaces implemented.
* Developing Scute::              How to understand or improve Scute.
* Mozilla Compatibility::         Interoperability notes for Mozilla NSS.
@end menu


@node Features and Limitations
@section Features and Limitations

Scute implements version 2.20 of the
@uref{http://www.rsasecurity.com/rsalabs/node.asp?id=2133, PKCS #11}
specification.

The @uref{http://www.g10code.com/p-card.html,OpenPGP smart card}
application is supported in read-only mode.

The following functions are not supported:

@table @code
@item C_Initialize
No support for native thread package.  Locking callbacks must be
provided if multi-threaded operation is desired.

@item C_WaitForSlotEvent
Not implemented.  The interface as specified by PKCS #11 is broken
anyway, as the function can not safely be canceled.  Thus, we require
polling.

@item C_GetOperationState
@itemx C_SetOperationState
Not supported.

@item C_InitToken

@itemx C_InitPIN
@itemx C_SetPIN
Not supported.  No write operations are allowed.  To configure the
token, please use the tools accompanying the GnuPG software suite.

@item C_Login
@itemx C_Logout
Not supported.  No login into the token by the software is required.
Passphrase queries are implemented by the use of GPG Agent and Pinentry.

@item C_EncryptInit
@itemx C_Encrypt
@itemx C_EncryptUpdate
@itemx C_EncryptFinal
@itemx C_DigestInit
@itemx C_Digest
@itemx C_DigestUpdate
@itemx C_DigestKey
@itemx C_DigestFinal
@itemx C_VerifyInit
@itemx C_Verify
@itemx C_VerifyUpdate
@itemx C_VerifyFinal
@itemx C_VerifyRecoverInit
@itemx C_VerifyRec
Not supported.  Only secret key operations are supported.

@item C_SignInit
@itemx C_Sign
Currently, only signing 36 bytes (MD5+SHA1) hashes is supported (used
for client authentication).

@item C_DecryptInit
@itemx C_Decrypt
Not yet supported, but will be in the future.

@item C_SignUpdate
@itemx C_SignFinal
@itemx C_DecryptUpdate
@itemx C_DecryptFinal
No progressive crypto-operations are supported.

@item C_SignRecoverInit
@itemx C_SignRecover
Not supported.

@item C_DigestEncryptUpdate
@itemx C_DecryptDigestUpdate
@itemx C_SignEncryptUpdate
@itemx C_DecryptVerifyUpdate
Dual-purpose cryptographic functions are not supported.

@item C_GenerateKey
@itemx C_GenerateKeyPair
@itemx C_WrapKey
@itemx C_UnwrapKey
@itemx C_DeriveKey
Key management functions are not supported.  Please use the tools
accompanying the GnuPG software suite to generate and import keys for
use with the token.

@item C_SeedRandom
@itemx C_GenerateRandom
Not supported at this point.  @code{C_GenerateRandom} may be supported
in the future, though.

@item C_CreateObject
@itemx C_CopyObject
@itemx C_DestroyObject
@itemx C_SetAttributeValue:
Only read-only operations are supported on objects.

@item C_GetObjectSize
Not supported.

@item CKO_CERTIFICATE
The label specifies the key on the card used (e.g. @code{OPENPGP.3}).
The ID is the fingerprint.

@item CKO_PRIVATE_KEY:
The @code{CKA_LOCAL} attribute can not be supported by the OpenPGP card.
It is always set to false (as the key on the card may be copied to the
card from an external source).
@end table

@node Developing Scute
@section Developing Scute

Scute is single-threaded.  There is a global lock that is taken in all
entry points of Scute, except for @code{C_Initialize},
@code{C_Finalize}, @code{C_GetFunctionList}, and stubs.

Here are a couple of hints on how to develop PKCS #11 modules for
Mozilla:

@code{libopensc2} ships with a @code{pkcs11-spy} library that can be
loaded as a wrapper around the PKCS #11 library you want to use to log
all functions invoked by Mozilla.  Here is how to use it:

Set the @code{PKCS11SPY_OUTPUT} environment variable to a filename.
@code{pkcs11-spy} appends its log messages at the end of this file.  Set
the @code{PKCS11SPY} environment variable to the filename of the PKCS
#11 module you actually want to use.  Start Mozilla within this
environment.

There is a different, probably more powerful way to debug Mozilla PKCS
#11 libraries.  However, to be able to use it, you need to configure and
compile the Mozilla NSS sources with @code{--enable-debug}.
Instructions can be found at:
@uref{http://www.mozilla.org/projects/security/pki/nss/tech-notes/tn2.html}

Here are a couple of links to more information about implementing a
PKCS #11 module for Mozilla:

@table @uref
@item http://docs.sun.com/source/816-6150-10/index.htm
@itemx http://docs.sun.com/source/816-6150-10/pkcs.htm
Implementing PKCS #11 for the Netscape Security Library (Caution: The
content may be out of date)

@item http://www.mozilla.org/projects/security/pki/pkcs11/netscape/problems.html
Common PKCS #11 Implementation Problems

@item http://www.mozilla.org/projects/security/pki/pkcs11/
PKCS #11 Conformance Testing

@item http://www.mozilla.org/projects/security/pki/nss/
The Mozilla NSS web page
@end table


@node Mozilla Compatibility
@section Mozilla Compatibility

Mozilla has a bug that causes the wrong security device to be unloaded
when unloading a security device.  Also, the displayed list becomes
corrupt. When closing and reopening the security device manager, the
list displayed is correct, but in anyway the wrong security module is
unloaded.


@include gpl.texi


@node Concept Index
@unnumbered Concept Index

@printindex cp


@summarycontents
@contents
@bye